There are many choices of video editing software available, from free to hundreds of dollars. With the increasing popularity of sharing via web 2.0 tools, audiences are expecting high quality, user-friendly applications that are low to no cost. I have evaluated several video editing software packages available at no cost, at least in their basic form.
Because I teach elementary, and our campus is Windows based, I am in search of software that meets certain criteria. I have used Windows MovieMaker with my students with great success, but wondered if there were other offerings that we could use that would meet our standards. Specifically we were looking for:
- FREE
- Installed easily onto older versions of Windows
- Kid-friendly
- Intuitive to use
- Basic functions such as importing media (video, audio, music, photo), addition of transitions, special effects, and titles
- Fun
VideoSpin
I looked through quite a few possibilities, and found one I felt was at the level of MovieMaker. The winner is: VideoSpin, by Pinnacle. To start with, I’m a sucker for “packaging”. After downloading, which was very easy, the working window came up and it was very colorful, organized, and modern. I know, you can’t judge a book by its cover, but I think there is something to be said about a group’s presentation of their product. If they take the time needed to upscale their workspace in its looks and organization, I feel they are going to take their time and do the rest of the project properly. VideoSpin did that.
VideoSpin is very easy to use. Remember, I have to teach 10 year olds how to use this, and frankly, I suspect if I just gave it to them and said, “try it out,” they would be showing me how it works. Importing files was very easy to do, and all of the desired functions are there, including some neat title screens.
VideoSpin has set up its screen layout in three areas: Album, Timeline, and Video Player.
The “album” area is like a storage bin for the video clips, titles, still photos, and sound effects. The “timeline” section is the area where you actually build your video, by dragging in pieces from your album. The last area is the “video player” where you can check your progress during the compilation of your project. All the areas are visible at the same time, so you always know what is going on.
You can start your project by importing into your album. VideoSpin gives you a menu of your computer folders to find your files. Pull the videos, pictures and music into the album for easy access. Once your album is loaded up, drag and drop pieces into the timeline. Move them around into different orders, and clip parts out by using the razorblade tool.
If you would like to put in some transitions to make your project flow, then use the transition tool in the album. Again, everything is dragged and dropped, exactly where you want to put things in the timeline. Drag in titles and music.
At any time, view your video in the video player. When you are happy, click on the “make movie” tab at the top of the screen. VideoSpin lets you choose from a variety of formats like AVI, MOV, Windows Media, and iPod compatible files. You can also upload to the web right from VideoSpin! I might actually like it better than MovieMaker.
iMovie
For a second evaluation, I tried to locate something new for Apple-Mac based computers. This is the platform I use at home. Yes, it is a huge hassle to go back and forth between the two! I’m adjusting. While I am new to the Mac, I was told it was the way to go for the more artistic computer user. So I thought I would run right out there and find a slew of free options. HA! This was not the case.
I did find two potential options with Jahshaka and Zweistein (ZS4). They were the easiest to use of all the open source options, and I liked how they were available on both Mac and Windows. However, I still wouldn’t use them over Apple’s iMovie.
iMovie is the easiest Mac based video editing software to use, and all Apple computers come with the package. Here are some reasons why I like it:
- Ease of use: It is set up similarly to the VideoSpin I discussed previously. There is a spot for all the tidbits you may want to include. I also like the way I can drag in pictures and sounds from my desktop easily. I hate reading instruction manuals! For the most part, I haven’t had to hit “help” to often in my video editing experiences.
- Functions: iMovie has a lot of functions available including transitions that are very modern and smooth, and can be time altered. Title screens are also available with the options to change fonts and colors. A variety of music and sound effects are also supplied for use, making personalization very easy.
- Narration ease: Audio clips have a lot of options when it comes to adjustments in sound, speed, lengths, etc. I can move them around easily, and their times are posted (as are the video lengths) so I can match up vocals and video.
- Export capabilities: I can export into a variety of files depending on how I will use the video. I can make an .m4v file or a .mov, and I can upload easily to several sites.
Overall, I’m getting used to the program, but I still don’t like how Mac uses certain file extensions that no one else does, and I sometimes have to use a converter for sound or video. But what really annoys me is there is no “save” button for the working window. I never feel confident about closing the program or surviving a crash without the option of “save”. It seems to hold everything in place though – so far…
I’m enjoying expressing myself using these tools. I can absolutely see the possibilities of new learning for myself, and my students when using the video creation option. In the past, my students have used Movie Maker to create an end of year summary of a science topic of their choice. But why wait? As we all become more knowledgeable and comfortable using these tools, I think the student can incorporate video editing, and digital storytelling throughout the year by producing shorter segments to relay their knowledge. I can absolutely use the software to create engaging segments as well.